We assess a book at the level appropriate to the evidence available. Bibliographic facts can be checked independently; personal reading experience requires a direct, human-approved record.

1. Identify the work and edition

We separate the language-neutral work from each language and ISBN edition. This prevents details from one translation or format being incorrectly applied to another.

2. Record what is verifiable

We check the title, author, language, ISBN, series position and other edition details. Publisher descriptions may help explain the premise, but they are not treated as our opinion.

3. Protect first-hand evidence

Household observations are published only when a person has approved them. Editing or translation may improve clarity, but must not change the meaning or create enthusiasm, criticism or certainty that was not present.

4. Make the recommendation useful

Where the evidence supports it, we explain the kind of reader, reading mood or decision the book may suit. A recommendation should help a family choose, not merely repeat a synopsis.

5. Review and correct

We update factual errors and clarify material changes. Readers can report a problem through our contact page.